Cash Balance
Plans

It is a pension plan that behaves like a savings account. Technically a defined benefit plan, presented to each participant as a hypothetical account balance that grows by two credits each year. For an owner with consistent profit it is usually the largest deductible contribution available.

How It Works

Each participant has a hypothetical account. It is not a real account holding their own investments, which is the detail that causes most of the confusion, but it is reported to them as a balance and it is easy to understand.

Two things are added to it each year.

  • A pay credit. A contribution defined in the plan document, either as a percentage of compensation or as a fixed dollar amount, and it can differ by participant group.
  • An interest credit. A rate specified in the plan document. Because the credited rate is defined rather than dependent on how the investments actually perform, the funding obligation sits with the employer, not the participant.

That last point is the one owners most need to understand. The plan promises the credited amounts. If the plan's actual investments return less than the credited rate, the employer makes up the shortfall. If they return more, future contributions may be reduced. The investment risk belongs to the business.

Why Owners Look at It

Defined contribution plans, including a 401(k) with profit sharing, have an annual limit per participant that applies equally regardless of age. A defined benefit plan works differently. Because the limit is expressed as a benefit payable at retirement rather than a contribution today, the amount that can be funded each year rises with age, as there are fewer years to fund it.

Practically this means an owner in their fifties or sixties with consistent profit can often contribute a multiple of what a 401(k) and profit sharing permit, and deduct it. That gap is the reason these plans exist for small businesses.

Specific limits are actuarially determined for each participant based on age, compensation and the plan's benefit formula, and they are subject to statutory maximums that are indexed annually. There is no single figure, which is why anyone quoting one without seeing your numbers is guessing.

What this covers

Cash Balance Plan vs Defined Benefit Plan

A reasonable source of confusion, because a cash balance plan is a defined benefit plan. The distinction is in how the benefit is expressed and how it feels to a participant.

  • How the benefit is stated

    Traditional defined benefit states a monthly income at retirement, often as a formula based on final average pay and years of service. Cash balance states a lump sum account balance.

  • How a participant experiences it

    Traditional is a promise that is hard to picture until retirement. Cash balance is a number on a statement that goes up each year, which participants understand immediately.

  • Portability

    Traditional benefits are typically taken as an annuity. Cash balance balances are usually portable as a lump sum, which suits a mobile workforce.

  • Funding

    Both are actuarially funded by the employer and both carry a funding obligation. Neither is discretionary.

  • Administration

    Both require an enrolled actuary and annual certification. Costs are broadly comparable.

  • Flexibility in design

    Cash balance pay credits can readily be set at different levels for different participant groups, which is often why it is chosen over a traditional design in a small business.

In short, most small businesses adopting a defined benefit plan today adopt a cash balance design, because it is easier to communicate and easier to tailor by group. The traditional structure still has its place, and that page covers when.

Why It Is Usually Paired With a 401(k)

These plans are rarely adopted alone. The common arrangement runs a 401(k) with profit sharing alongside a cash balance plan, because the two interact under the testing rules and the combination can be designed more efficiently than either on its own.

The combined design also gives the business a flexible component and a fixed one. The profit sharing contribution can move with the year. The cash balance contribution largely cannot. Having both means not every dollar is committed.

What You Are Committing To

This is where the conversation should slow down, and where we would rather talk an owner out of a plan than into one.

  • Funding is substantially mandatory. Once established, the contribution is an obligation rather than a decision, and a year of poor profit does not remove it. There are limited circumstances in which a plan can be amended or frozen, and those have their own requirements.
  • Employees are included. If the business has staff, they participate, and the cost of their benefits is part of the arithmetic. For a practice with a small owner group and a large staff the economics can be unattractive.
  • An actuary is required. The plan must be certified annually by an enrolled actuary. That is a real recurring cost and a real professional relationship, not a formality.
  • It expects a horizon. These plans are generally intended to be maintained for a number of years. Establishing one with the intention of closing it after two is likely to attract scrutiny.
  • Investment responsibility sits with the plan. Because the credited rate is defined, returns above or below it are the employer’s concern. This usually argues for a more conservative investment approach inside the plan than an owner might choose personally.

Who It Tends to Suit

From the plans we see work well, a pattern repeats. Consistent profit over several years rather than one strong year. An owner typically in their late forties or older, since the funding advantage grows with age. A desire to contribute meaningfully more than defined contribution limits allow. A workforce small enough, or structured such, that the employee cost is manageable. And a horizon of several years before winding down.

Missing one of those does not rule it out. Missing three usually does, and that is worth establishing before anyone pays for a plan design.

A Hypothetical Illustration

Two partners in a professional practice, both in their mid-fifties, with six employees mostly in their thirties. Profit has been consistent for seven years. Both partners are contributing the maximum to a 401(k) with profit sharing and want to put away considerably more before they stop working.The modelling looked at three things: what a cash balance design would permit for each partner given their ages and compensation, what the required contributions for the six employees would cost annually, and what the combined structure meant for the practice’s cash flow in a weaker year.The arithmetic worked, partly because the age gap between the partners and the staff made the design efficient. In a practice where the staff were closer in age to the owners the answer might have been different. That is why it is modelled rather than assumed.

Frequently Asked Questions

A pension plan presented as an account balance. The employer funds it, each participant sees a balance that grows by a defined pay credit and a defined interest credit each year, and the employer carries the investment risk. It is a defined benefit plan wearing the clothes of a savings account.

There is no single figure. Limits are actuarially determined for each participant based on age, compensation and the plan’s benefit formula, and they are subject to statutory maximums that are indexed annually. Age is the dominant variable, which is why the same plan permits very different amounts for a forty-year-old and a sixty-year-old. We confirm the current figures for your situation during planning.

It is a type of defined benefit plan. The difference is presentation and design flexibility. A traditional plan states a monthly income at retirement. A cash balance plan states a lump sum balance, which participants find easier to understand, and the pay credits can more readily be set at different levels for different groups.

Generally yes, subject to eligibility rules in the plan document. The cost of employee benefits is part of the economics and should be modelled before adoption rather than discovered afterwards.

The funding obligation does not disappear. There are limited routes to amend or freeze a plan and they carry their own requirements and consequences. This is the main reason we ask hard questions about profit consistency before a plan is established.

Yes, and that is the usual arrangement. The two interact under the testing rules and the combination is generally designed together rather than separately.

Setup, annual third party administration, annual actuarial certification, and the contributions themselves. The professional fees are a recurring and meaningful cost. They should be set against the deduction, not ignored.

There is no fixed term, but these plans are intended to be maintained rather than opened and closed opportunistically. A plan terminated after a very short period is likely to attract attention. Plan on a horizon of several years.

More in Business Owner Planning

Related Services

Business Owner Financial Planning

View

401(k) & Profit Sharing Plans

View

Defined Benefit Plans

View

Business Succession & Exit Planning

View

ESOP Strategies

View