A conversion moves money from an account taxed on the way out to one taxed on the way in. Inside a retirement plan, the decision is about timing, not preference — the same conversion can cost very different amounts in different retirement years.
WHAT A CONVERSION IS
Converting moves assets from a tax-deferred retirement account into a Roth account. The amount converted is generally included in income in the year it happens, which means you are electing to pay tax now on money you would otherwise be taxed on later, when required withdrawals begin.
That makes it one of the few tax decisions in a retirement plan you fully control the timing of: which years carry the tax, and which do not. Which is also what makes it easy to get wrong.
THE WINDOW
For many people there is a stretch between the end of employment income and the start of required withdrawals from retirement accounts. Income during those years is often materially lower than it was before and than it will be again.
That stretch is the widest planning window most households will have. It can be several years long, it closes on a schedule set by law rather than by choice, and a great deal of what can be done with it has to be decided in advance. We meet a lot of people who learn about it after it has closed.
WHEN IT MAY NOT FIT
CONVERTING ACROSS YEARS
Converting an entire balance in a single year can push the amount through several brackets and trigger effects that have nothing to do with income tax. Spreading conversions across several years, sized to fill a bracket rather than overflow it, is the more common approach.
How many years, and how much in each, depends on the other income in those years, the state position, and what the money is ultimately for. The decision is normally made over years, not in a single meeting.
WHAT ELSE MOVES
A conversion raises income in the year it happens, and several things are calculated off income that have nothing to do with the converted account. Most often those are:
None of these make conversions a bad idea. They make the sizing of a conversion a different exercise than the retirement calculation it sits inside.
WHERE THE LINE SITS
We do not prepare returns or provide tax advice, and a conversion has consequences that belong in front of a tax professional who knows the full return. We work with the rest of the plan; the tax filing follows.
A SITUATION WE SEE
A practice owner sells at 62 and has four years before required withdrawals begin. His income in those years is low because the practice is gone and withdrawals have not yet started. He converts a set amount each year, sized to the bracket he is still sitting in, and by the time withdrawals begin the Roth position carries a meaningful amount of the plan. If the structure had not been set up with the new entity in place, the planning wouldn’t be the only thing affected — the tax outcome would change as well, because income would have had nowhere to go.
See also Tax-Efficient Retirement Planning, Retirement Income Planning and Social Security Planning.
Converting a portion of a tax-deferred balance in each of several consecutive years rather than all at once, with each year’s amount sized against that year’s income and brackets. The point is to avoid pushing a single year’s income higher than it needs to go.
There is no general answer, but there is usually a better window, and for many people it sits between the end of employment income and the start of required withdrawals. Where that falls for you depends on your circumstances.
Rarely. A full conversion in one year typically pushes income through multiple brackets and can trigger effects well beyond income tax. Having some balance remain in a tax-deferred account also preserves flexibility, including for charitable strategies later.
Ideally from outside the converted amount. Paying it from the conversion itself reduces the balance that goes on to grow, which undercuts much of the reason for doing it. If there is no outside source, that is a reason to look hard at whether the conversion fits.
The converted amount is generally included in California income as well, without preferential treatment. For a California resident this means the state cost of a conversion is a real part of the calculation rather than a rounding item, and it should be modelled alongside the federal position.
Treat it as permanent. The ability to reverse a conversion was removed some years ago. That is precisely why sizing it correctly in advance matters more than it used to.
More in Retirement Planning