What you hold matters. Where you hold it, and when you trade it, matters as well.
ASSET LOCATION
Most investors have heard of asset allocation. Fewer have thought about asset location, which is the question of which account each holding belongs in.
Different account types treat the same income differently. An investment that throws off income taxed at ordinary rates behaves differently in a tax-deferred account than in a taxable one. An investment expected to grow substantially behaves differently again in an account where growth may come out tax-free. The holdings do not change. The accounts they sit in do.
This is one of the few areas where the decision is nearly free to get right at the outset and genuinely expensive to correct later, because correcting it usually means selling something.
WHAT THIS COVERS
REALISING LOSSES
When a holding in a taxable account is worth less than it cost, selling it realises a loss that can be set against realised gains. If losses exceed gains, a limited amount can generally be applied against ordinary income each year, with the remainder carried forward.
There are rules about what you may buy back and when, and getting that wrong undoes the benefit. There is also a judgement question underneath it, which is whether a sale made for tax reasons is a sale you would otherwise want to make. Harvesting a loss in a holding you wanted to keep solves one problem and creates another.
TIMING
Gains on investments held beyond a threshold period are generally treated differently at the federal level from gains on investments held for less. The practical consequence is that a sale eleven weeks earlier and a sale eleven weeks later can be taxed differently.
California adds a wrinkle worth knowing about. The state does not apply a separate preferential rate to long-term gains, so the federal distinction does not carry through at state level. For a California resident in the upper brackets, that changes the arithmetic of a sale. It is one of the clearest examples of why a strategy that works in another state should be checked here.
WHERE THE LINE SITS
We do not prepare returns or provide tax advice. What is described here is how investment decisions are approached with their tax consequences in view, and every specific is confirmed with your tax professional before it is acted on.
A SITUATION WE SEE
A pharmacist holds a single stock bought twenty years ago that now represents a large share of her taxable account. The cost basis is very low. Selling it in one year would realise a substantial gain in a state that taxes it as ordinary income. Doing nothing leaves her concentrated in one company. Neither extreme is the answer, and the useful work is in what sits between them, usually over several years.
See also Tax-Aware Financial Planning for how this fits the wider method, Income Tax Planning for the bracket and timing side, and Portfolio Management.
If nobody has looked at which account holds what, that is usually the first thing worth reviewing.
Allocation is what you own and in what proportion. Location is which account each holding sits in. Allocation gets most of the attention. Location is where a meaningful part of the after-tax difference comes from.
It depends on whether there are gains to offset, whether the holding is one you wanted to keep anyway, and what the transaction costs. It is a useful tool and it is not automatically worth doing. Anyone who tells you it always is has not looked at your situation.
Tax is one input, not the deciding one. A concentrated position carries investment risk that does not go away because selling would be expensive. The work is in weighing both, usually across more than one tax year.
They can, and whether they do depends on your bracket, the alternatives available and what the rest of the portfolio is doing. It is a question with a real answer, but it is a per-household answer rather than a general one.
Some of it does not. Realising a loss inside a tax-deferred account produces no deduction, and trading inside one does not generate a current tax event. That is precisely why asset location matters: the same decision has different consequences depending on where it happens.
More in Tax & Financial Planning