What matters is how the policy defines being unable to work, and whose job it measures that against.
WHY THIS ONE FIRST
A physician, dentist or pharmacist has usually spent a decade building an earning capacity that depends on being able to do a specific job. Everything else in the plan is funded by that capacity. If it stops, nothing else works as intended.
Life insurance is the risk people think about. For someone in their thirties or forties, the probability of being unable to work for an extended period is considerably higher than the probability of dying. It gets less attention because it is harder to picture.
THE FEATURES THAT MATTER
and whether you could manage that long
which for a younger professional is the difference between a setback and a disaster
for a reduced capacity rather than a complete inability to work
which matters most for someone early in their earnings curve
since a benefit set today is being measured against costs decades from now
THE DEFINITION
Every disability policy contains a definition of what it means to be disabled. That definition determines whether a claim is paid, and it varies enormously between policies.
An own occupation definition generally assesses whether you can perform the duties of your own occupation, the one you were working in. Under that kind of definition, a surgeon who can no longer operate may qualify even if she is capable of other work.
An any occupation definition generally assesses whether you can perform the duties of any occupation you are reasonably suited to by education, training or experience. That is a materially harder test to meet, and the same surgeon may not qualify.
Many policies use one definition for an initial period and then switch to the other. That switch is frequently the single most important thing in the contract and frequently the thing the owner does not know about.
NOT ALL OWN OCCUPATION IS THE SAME
Own occupation is used loosely. Some versions pay a benefit if you cannot perform your own occupation regardless of whether you work elsewhere. Some reduce or cease the benefit if you take other work. Some are written against a broad occupational category rather than the specific specialty you practice.
For a specialist, whether the definition measures against the specialty or against the broader profession can be the difference between a claim paid and a claim declined. It is a contract question, and the answer is in the contract rather than the brochure.
GROUP PLANS
Group disability cover through an employer, a hospital or a professional association is common and it is usually the only cover someone has. The recurring limitations are worth knowing before relying on it.
None of this makes group cover a bad thing. It makes it a floor rather than a plan.
WHERE THE LINE SITS
Franklin Mohri holds California Insurance Licence 0C71568 and insurance products are offered through various underwriting companies. Definitions, features and availability differ between carriers and policies. Whether any cover is available to you, and on what terms, is determined by the carrier’s underwriting of your application including your occupation and health.
A SITUATION WE SEE
A dentist relies on cover through a professional association. He develops a hand tremor and can no longer perform clinical work, though he could teach or consult. Whether the policy responds depends entirely on which definition applies at that point in the contract. He had never read it, and the time to have read it was before he needed it. This is an illustrative situation and does not describe a specific client.
See also Insurance Planning, Physicians, Dentists and Medical Practice Owners.
Send us the policy. The useful conversation starts with what it actually says. Request a private intro call →
It describes a definition of disability that generally assesses whether you can perform the duties of your own occupation rather than any occupation you might be suited to. For a specialist whose income depends on specific capabilities, that distinction determines whether a claim is paid. The exact wording varies by policy and should be read rather than assumed.
It depends on the cap, the definition, whether it is portable and how benefits would be taxed. For higher earners the cap frequently binds, and the definition is often the bigger issue. Read the plan document rather than the benefits summary.
It generally depends on who paid the premium and with what. The difference between a taxable and a non-taxable benefit is significant when you are sizing cover. Confirm the treatment for your situation with your tax professional.
Because the work depends on specific capabilities that can be lost without the person being unable to work at all. A definition that measures against any occupation may not respond in exactly the circumstances a clinician is most exposed to. That is why the definition matters more than the benefit amount.
Underwriting assesses age and health, and options to increase coverage later without new medical underwriting are generally easier to obtain while both are favorable. Whether it is the right use of money at that stage depends on your circumstances.
An individual policy you own is generally portable. Group cover through an employer or association generally is not, and the options to continue it are usually time-limited. This is one of the main practical differences between the two.
More in Insurance & Risk Management