Charitable
Giving

The same gift, funded differently or timed differently, can produce a different result for the donor.

What you give is your decision. How you give it is a planning one.

HOW A GIFT IS FUNDED

Cash is the default. It is not always the most effective route.

Most people give cash because it is simple. For a donor holding appreciated investments in a taxable account, giving the asset itself rather than selling it first can work differently, because the sale and the gift are two separate events with separate consequences.

The charity generally receives the same value either way. What changes is what happens on the donor's side. For someone with a concentrated position or a holding with a very low cost basis, this is one of the more useful conversations available.

WHERE THE MONEY SITS

Donor advised fund, charitable trust, or direct.

  • Direct giving

    The simplest route. Suits regular giving to known organisations where no timing or structural question is involved.

  • Donor advised fund

    Contribute now, recommend grants over time. Useful when the year the gift is made and the year the charity receives it are better separated, including after a liquidity event.

  • Charitable trust

    More structure, more complexity, and a legal instrument that requires counsel. Used where income, timing and the ultimate charitable gift need to be arranged together.

  • From a retirement account

    For donors at the relevant age, giving directly from certain retirement accounts can be treated differently from giving cash. Eligibility and treatment should be confirmed with your tax professional.

Spread evenly, or concentrated into one year.

WHEN IT LANDS

A household that gives a similar amount every year has a choice about how that giving is recognized. Spreading it across years and concentrating several years of giving into one can produce different outcomes depending on where income falls and how deductions work out in a given year.

This is the practice usually described as bunching, and it is one of the clearest examples of a planning decision that changes a result without changing what anyone actually gives.

A liquidity year changes the arithmetic.

GIVING AROUND AN EVENT

The year a practice is sold, a business is exited or a concentrated position is unwound is often a year of unusually high income. It is also, for donors who already intended to give, frequently the most effective year to do it.

The planning has to happen before the transaction rather than after it, which is why this conversation belongs alongside the exit planning rather than at the end of the year.

Planning and coordination, not tax or legal advice.

WHERE THE LINE SITS

We do not prepare tax returns, provide tax advice or draft legal documents. Charitable structures have tax and legal consequences that belong with your tax professional and, where a trust is involved, your attorney. What we do is work through the options and make sure the right people see the plan before it is executed.

The year the practice sold.

A SITUATION WE SEE

A dentist who has given to the same two organisations for fifteen years sells her practice. Her income that year is several times its normal level. She intends to keep giving at roughly the same annual rate for the rest of her life. Whether that giving is more effective done as usual, or concentrated into the year of the sale through a structure that lets the grants continue at the same pace, is a question with a real answer and a short window to decide it in. This is an illustrative situation and does not describe a specific client.

See also Tax & Financial Planning, Business Exit Planning, Legacy Planning and Income Tax Planning.

If you give regularly and have never looked at how, that is usually worth an hour.

Request a private intro call →

Frequently Asked Questions

A donor advised fund is an account at a sponsoring organisation. You contribute, then recommend grants over time. It is simpler, cheaper to establish and does not require legal drafting. A charitable trust is a legal instrument with its own terms and its own administration, used where the arrangement needs more structure than a fund can provide. The trust requires an attorney. The fund generally does not.

It depends on what you hold and in which account. Where a holding in a taxable account has appreciated significantly, giving the asset itself rather than selling first may work differently on the donor’s side. Confirm the treatment for your situation with your tax professional.

Concentrating several years of planned giving into a single year rather than spreading it evenly, usually to align it with how deductions work out in that year. The charity can still receive the same annual amount if the gift is routed through a structure that allows grants over time.

For donors at the relevant age, giving directly from certain retirement accounts to a qualifying charity can be treated differently from giving cash. Eligibility, limits and the mechanics should be confirmed with your tax professional before anything is sent.

No. Most of what is described here applies to households that give consistently, whatever the amount. The structural questions become more valuable as giving grows or when a liquidity event is involved, but the basic question of how a gift is funded applies broadly.

Before the year closes, and before any transaction that will change your income. A conversation in December leaves fewer options than one in June, and a conversation after a sale leaves fewer again.

More in Estate & Legacy Planning

Related Services

Estate Planning Coordination

View

Legacy Planning

View

Wealth Transfer Planning

View